The Future of Space: Orbital Congestion, Commerce, Nationalism & Inspiration
Hot Nerd Summer #4 The fourth session of Hot Nerd Summer turned to space — and to the gap between what we can now do above the atmosphere and the rules, the money, and the motives that govern it. The discussion took on orbital congestion and the near-total absence of enforceable governance, the commercial gold rush and whose business case actually closes, asteroid mining as a driver of wealth disparity, and the uneasy relationship between science, nationalism, and private capital. Held under the Chatham House Rule, with voices from NASA, the astronaut corps, planetary science, and public finance. Selected, unattributed quotes below.
Main Guests
Sean O'Keefe
Former NASA Administrator
Gideon Lichfield
Journalist · Moderator
Cady Coleman
Former NASA astronaut · 159 days aboard the ISS
Gretchen Rubin
Author on happiness & human nature
Megan Donahue
Astrophysicist, Michigan State · Former President, American Astronomical Society
Terry Virts
Former NASA astronaut · Former ISS commander
Lindy Elkins-Tanton
Director, Space Sciences Laboratory, UC Berkeley · PI, NASA Psyche mission
David Walker
Former U.S. Comptroller General
Timothy Ferris
Science writer · Producer, the Voyager Golden Record
Sarah Pousho
Co-founder & CEO, Space Bridge Partners
and more...
From the discussion
A decade ago there were roughly 2,500 space assets in orbit. Today that number is 34,000.
“There's not much control over any of it. Only a small number are even in a position to avoid a collision.
“We do have space law. The problem is that it's virtually unenforceable.
“We have no business case that closes outside of Earth orbit. Everything profitable we do in space is looking back at Earth.
“This is the California Gold Rush, and these companies are selling mules and gold pans. They're not mining.
“If people succeed in mining metal asteroids, it's the greatest chance for wealth disparity humankind has ever seen.
“As long as going to the Moon and Mars is about nationalism, it won't be about peace, equity, or following laws. It'll be about pushing boundaries.
“Science, for the history of humans, has been a ride-along. Darwin went on the Beagle to keep the depressive captain from killing himself — that wasn't a science trip.
“AI companies and the space companies are increasingly in the hands of a few very wealthy individuals — and that's an amount of control we haven't grappled with.
“Every dollar we spend on a space mission is spent here on Earth — on groceries, on rent, on the machinist who can make the part no one else can make.
“Poverty could have been solved with that budget long ago if it were that simple. There's a difference between a wicked problem and a directed project.
“Astronomy is the great gateway drug to science and engineering.
“The point of space exploration is to scrape the last crumb off the plate of human arrogance.
Digital Battlefield Group convenes senior leaders from government, industry, and academia to discuss intelligence and national security in the age of AI. All events operate under Chatham House Rule.
Learn more about DBG →